Avoiding Etsy Scams: A Safety Guide

Stay secure on Etsy by learning how to identify scam messages, verify site authenticity, and take action if you encounter fraud.

In the bustling marketplace of Etsy, where creativity thrives, it’s crucial to stay vigilant against scams that target our community. We are dedicated to equipping you with the knowledge to protect your business from these threats.

Recognizing Authentic Etsy Communications

Etsy takes great care in ensuring that authentic communications are easily identifiable. Look for messages under the “From Etsy” label within your dedicated From Etsy inbox on the platform. This is your first line of defense; if a message claiming to be from an employee isn’t there, treat it with suspicion—report it as spam and do not engage further. Scammers often cast a wide net, sending identical or generic messages to numerous sellers at once—particularly those offering higher-priced items. A message lacking personalization could be a red flag indicating a scam attempt.

Remember: Legitimate representatives from Etsy will never request your password nor make unsolicited phone calls without previous notification. Beware of any unsolicited calls or numbers posted online—they may lead you into a trap set by scammers. Stay one step ahead by reviewing the Account Security Checklist featured in the Seller Handbook for comprehensive steps on fortifying your account against unauthorized access.

Identifying Authenticity: Official Messages From Etsy

While messages originating from Etsy can feature a range of subject lines, their location in your From Etsy folder is consistent across the board.

Here’s what you can expect an official message from Etsy to look like within your From Etsy folder.

Phishing attempts are crafty; even when a message bears semblance to those sent by Etsy but is situated outside of the From Etsy section—such as in your main inbox or other folders—it’s likely fraudulent. Mark these as spam without engagement.

Recognizing Phishing Attempts: A Closer Look

Phishing scams can take various forms within your inbox. Different avatars or faux-Etsy branding might be used in such deceptive tactics. The critical indicator remains whether or not the communication is housed within the exclusive From Etsy tab – if not, consider it dubious.

This example demonstrates what an unauthentic message looks like when it has not been filed under the From Etsy category.

Guide to Marking Messages as Spam

Engaging with potential scammers only leads to trouble. Therefore, if you come across a message that raises suspicion, do not respond. Follow these steps to safely mark the message as spam:

  1. Log in at Etsy.com and proceed to Your Account.
  2. Navigate directly to your Messages.
  3. From your inbox list, click on the questionable message.
  4. Click on Mark as Spam.

By marking it as spam, you’re moving the conversation away from your main inbox and into the Spam folder—a crucial step in keeping your workspace organized and free from potential threats.

How to Change Your Etsy Email Preferences

You can opt-in and out of most Etsy emails. Opting out isn’t an option for certain emails Etsy is required by law to send, like notifications to the buyer and seller when an order is purchased and when we update our Terms of Use. Here’s how you can adjust your Etsy email preferences as part of a comprehensive approach to enhance the overall security framework for your online business:

  1. On Etsy.com, go to Your account.
  2. Click Account Settings.
  3. Click the Emails tab.
  4. Under Your Notifications and Your Subscriptions, select or deselect which emails you’ll receive.
  5. Choose Save Settings.
Etsy’s Account Settings

Understanding and Identifying Scammer Strategies

Scammers are becoming increasingly cunning, but certain behaviors should immediately set off your internal alarms. Be wary if you encounter any of the following:

For All Etsy Members:

  • Unusual Communication Requests: If someone insists on taking the conversation off Etsy’s platform to a personal email address, be cautious.
  • Alternate Payment Methods: A message suggesting payment through an external platform instead of Etsy’s checkout can be a scam. Such transactions bypass Etsy’s Purchase Protection, leaving you vulnerable.
  • Urgency to Complete Transactions: Creating a false sense of urgency is a common pressure tactic used by scammers.

For Sellers Specifically:

  • Troubled ‘Buyers’: Beware of anyone pretending to have difficulties checking out and requesting your email under the pretext that it’s necessary for completing their purchase.
  • Fake Payment Issues: Watch out for messages about payment problems accompanied by QR codes or links—they could be phishing attempts.
  • Additional Purchase Requests: Requests for adding unrelated high-value items such as gift cards might be part of a scam known as the overpayment scam.
  • Suspicious Links: Be cautious with links claiming to showcase items—these could direct you to malicious sites.
  • Overpayment Offers: An offer to pay more than the asking price for an item should immediately raise suspicion; this is often tied to fraudulent activities.

By familiarizing yourself with these common techniques used by scammers targeting both buyers and sellers, you can better protect your business from fraudulent activities.

Authentication of Etsy’s Website

Scammers often create counterfeit websites that mimic reputable sites like Etsy. To confirm the legitimacy of an Etsy page, pay close attention to the URL in your web browser’s address bar:

By double-checking this small detail, you can protect yourself from falling prey to fraudulent sites designed to deceive and exploit unsuspecting users.

Here is an example of a legitimate page on Etsy with a URL starting with Etsy.com

What Steps to Take if You Fall Victim to a Scam

Unfortunately, scams can sometimes succeed despite our best efforts. If you find yourself having exchanged money with someone you suspect is a scammer:

  1. Report Immediately: Contact local law enforcement authorities as soon as possible.
  2. Notify Your Financial Institution: Reach out to your bank or credit card company immediately—to report fraudulent transactions and explore options such as chargebacks or fraud protection services they may offer.
  3. Keep Records: Gather all communications and documentation related to the scam—emails, messages, transaction receipts—as these will be critical for investigations by both law enforcement and financial institutions.
  4. Etsy Support: Report the incident directly to Etsy’s support team so they can take appropriate action against fraudulent accounts.
  5. Stay Informed: Regularly check updates provided by local government agencies regarding online scams—staying informed helps prevent future incidents.

Your Essential Account Security Checklist

Leverage the following checklist as part of your regular security routine to enhance the protection of your Etsy account:

1. Enable Two-Factor Authentication

Boost your login security by enabling two-factor authentication. This requires both a password and a verification code sent to your device, providing an added layer of defense against unauthorized access.

2. Create Robust Passwords

Passwords are often the first line of defense. Ensure yours are long, varied, and creative—combine letters, numbers, and symbols for optimal strength. Regularly check if any passwords have been compromised using tools like haveibeenpwned.com, update them every six months or so via Account Settings, and consider using a reliable password manager.

3. Conduct Transactions on Etsy Only

For both communication and transactions, stick to using Etsy Messages and Checkout. Should issues arise with buyers or sellers, having all interactions on-platform allows Etsy Support to assist effectively.

4. Recognize Suspicious Messages

Be vigilant about messages that convey urgency or request personal information hastily—these could be scam attempts. Don’t click links from unverified sources; instead, directly access any necessary sections through logged-in sessions on Etsy.com.

5. Keep Contact Details Current

Update phone numbers and email addresses linked to your account regularly through Account Settings > Email. This ensures you’ll receive timely notifications regarding two-factor authentication prompts or unusual activity alerts.

6. Limit Account Access

Restrict access to those who absolutely need it in order to avoid unauthorized changes or password resets—it’s crucial for maintaining accountability for all account activity per Etsy’s Terms of Use.

7. Update Financial and Tax Information

Regularly review your Shop Manager > Finances > Payment Settings to detect any unusual activity early on. Keeping your taxpayer information accurate is also key to avoiding disruptions due to payment controls and preparing for tax filings.

8. Stay Informed on Device Security

Protecting your devices is as vital as securing your account details:

  • Clear old devices before transitioning to new ones by removing personal info and restoring factory settings.
  • Change preset passwords for Wi-Fi networks and routers for unique protection.
  • Stay updated with the latest software, including antivirus programs, and ensure you’re using official Etsy apps or the website when managing your shop.
  • Monitor sign-in history regularly through account security settings, remaining alert for unfamiliar devices or third-party connections.

9. Get Support When You Need It

Etsy offers expanded real-time support channels 24/7 via live chat, phone calls, or email—especially designed for sellers with at least one sale. If you suspect a compromise or need assistance, reach out through the Etsy Help Center. Always report suspicious messages and consult the help center for common concerns.

Conclusion

In conclusion, as an Etsy shop owner, the delicate balance between accessibility and security should always be a priority. By implementing the robust measures outlined in this article, you will not only safeguard your business but also contribute to the integrity of the entire Etsy community. The digital marketplace thrives on trust—trust that sellers will provide quality goods and services, and trust that buyers’ information and transactions are secure.

Remember that security is an ongoing process, not a one-time setup. It requires vigilance, awareness, and adaptability as new threats emerge and technology evolves. Stay informed about best practices for online security; Etsy continuously updates its features and protections to keep pace with changing cyber landscapes.

FAQ

Etsy Scam Alert - Recognizing Fraudulent Messages & Protecting Your Store
How can I tell if a message on Etsy is a scam?
Be cautious of messages that insist on off-site communication, urge immediate action, or request payments outside of Etsy. Scammers may also express undue interest in high-value items or use vague inquiries that show they haven’t read your listing details. Always trust your instincts—if something feels off, it probably is.
What are the common signs of an overpayment scam on Etsy?
An overpayment scam typically involves a buyer offering to pay more than the asking price for an item. The scammer then requests the excess amount to be returned or asks for additional purchases like gift cards to be included with the order. Such offers should immediately raise suspicion.
How do I ensure I'm actually on the legitimate Etsy website and not a fake site?
To confirm you're on the real Etsy website, always check the URL in your browser’s address bar; it should start with "http://etsy.com/" or "http://help.etsy.com/." Be wary of any other variation that could indicate a fraudulent site designed to mimic Etsy's official appearance.
What should I do if I suspect I've been targeted by a scammer on Etsy?
If you suspect you've encountered a scammer, cease all communication and report them directly through Etsy's reporting system. You should also consider informing local law enforcement and contacting your financial institution if any money has been exchanged.
Can transactions made offsite from Etsy be covered by Purchase Protection?
No, transactions made offsite are not eligible for Purchase Protection offered by Etsy. Always complete transactions through the official Etsy Checkout process to ensure you're covered by their protection policies against fraudulent activities.