Identifying Spam and Suspicious Messages on Etsy: A Guide for Sellers

Discover practical strategies to identify, manage and report suspicious activities on your Etsy shop for a safer selling experience

As an Etsy seller, it’s essential to understand how to identify and handle spam or suspicious messages. Scammers often target online platforms like Etsy, using various tactics to trick unsuspecting sellers. This article provides guidelines on how to protect yourself from fraudulent activities and maintain the integrity of your online store.

Recognizing Authentic Messages from Etsy

With the increasing number of scams, differentiating between authentic messages from Etsy staff and potential scam attempts is crucial for your safety. Genuine messages from Etsy will always include an Etsy staff verification badge. If someone claims to represent Etsy but lacks this badge in their communication, refrain from replying.

Spotting Scammers

Scammers often use a similar approach - creating multiple accounts on Etsy, sending identical messages to various sellers with little personalization, and targeting those who list high-priced items in their shops.

Identifying Scam Techniques

Here are some common techniques scammers employ:

  • Impersonation: Pretending to be buyers having issues at checkout and asking for your email under the guise of completing their purchase.
  • Payment Issues: They claim they couldn’t make a payment for their order and send you a fake QR code through Messages that they say confirm their purchase.
  • Additional Item Requests: Asking you to add high-priced gift cards or other items to their order with promises of reimbursement later.
  • Phishing Links: Providing links that lead to malware or phishing sites instead of legitimate product pages.
  • Overpayment Scams: Offering more money than what you asked for your item.
  • Outside Communication Requests: Insisting on communicating off-site via personal email addresses immediately after initial contact.
  • Vague Questions: Asking questions without any reference to your listing details can also indicate potential scams.

If you notice any combination of these signs, proceed with caution.

Taking Action Against Suspicious Messages

Etsy advises against engaging with suspicious messages as it may encourage further scam attempts. Follow these steps if you receive a suspicious message:

  1. Sign into your account on Etsy.
  2. Navigate towards Messages.
  3. Select the suspicious message in question.
  4. Mark it as “Spam”.

Doing so moves the message out of your inbox into the spam folder but doesn’t stop emails about new replies in that conversation thread. To stop receiving such notifications, follow the instructions provided here.

Marking a suspicious message as spam on Etsy’s Shop Manager Message Settings

To retrieve the message back into your inbox again:

  1. Go into your Spam folder
  2. Select the message
  3. Choose Not Spam
Etsy Shop Manager's Spam Message Inbox

Is Selling on Etsy Safe?

While online selling inherently carries some risks, selling on Etsy is generally safe due to the platform’s measures in verifying payments. However, scammers can still pose as customers, so it’s crucial to be aware and take precautions.

Etsy has implemented policies like the Purchase Protection Program and others designed to prevent fee evasion that inadvertently protects sellers from scams. When you know what to watch out for, you’re one step closer to safeguarding yourself against fraudulent activities.

Protecting Yourself as an Etsy Seller

To shield yourself from scams targeting Etsy sellers:

1. Keep Transactions On-Site

Some seller-targeted scams involve customers requesting off-site purchases which could expose the seller to potential verification issues. By keeping all transactions within Etsy’s ecosystem, you’ll evade many scam attempts.

2. Pause Before Shipping

Due to recent instances of order cancellations after approval by Etsy due to fraudulent payments detected post-factum, it’s prudent for sellers not to ship orders out immediately. Waiting at least 24 hours before shipping could save you from losing both your product and payment.

3. Ship To The Registered Address

Always ship your products strictly according to the address provided during order placement. It helps protect both parties under the Purchase Protection Program while avoiding potential credit card fraud or dropshipping attempts by less scrupulous individuals.

If a customer requests a change of address post-order placement, ask them instead to cancel and re-place their order with the correct address details filled in.

4. Handle Non-delivery Claims Wisely

In instances where a customer claims non-receipt of a package despite delivery confirmation via tracking status updates, don’t rush into offering refunds until all avenues for package recovery have been explored with the postal services involved. If necessary, remind them that mail theft is a federal crime - this often weeds out false claimants.

If all else fails and the package was indeed stolen or misdelivered without help from postal service providers recover it, let your customer open a case with Etsy so they can submit a purchase protection program request. If eligible (sent with tracking or via Etsy labels etc.), they may qualify for cost coverage by Etsy itself.

5. Be Aware Of Other Scam Types

Apart from payment-related scams mentioned above, there are also other types of scams such as fake charity donation requests or bogus influencer promotional offers which target unsuspecting vendors. Be vigilant when approaching influencers and bloggers requesting free product reviews – ensure the person has a genuine engagement audience on social media before making a decision.

Overall being vigilant and informed about various scamming tactics will go a long way in safeguarding your online business on platforms like Etsy. As they say - knowledge is power!

Common Types of Etsy Scams

While Etsy provides a safe platform for you to sell your products, it isn’t entirely immune to fraudulent activities. Scammers often create multiple accounts and target sellers with high-priced items in their shops but few sales. In this article, we delve into the different types of scams on Etsy and how you can protect yourself.

1) Phishing Emails

Phishing is a cybercrime where the scammer pretends to be a known organization, asking for your personal information. With phishing emails, scammers force you into logging into your account on a fake site that imitates Etsy’s platform – thereby stealing your login credentials and possibly even payment information.

Example:

"Hello, I am having difficulties making payments on Etsy. Could you help me resolve this issue by clicking on this link to verify your account?”

2) Too-Good-To-Be-True Offers

Scammers may list products at unusually low prices compared to other sellers on the platform. These listings usually come with attractive images (often photoshopped or completely fake), convincing you about the product’s quality and value.

Example:

"I noticed you have an item priced at $500 in your shop. If I pay today, can we agree on a deal for $200?”

3) Urgency Tactics

Scammers often employ urgency tactics demanding immediate action - they may claim an emergency situation or threaten legal consequences if not obeyed instantly.

Example:

"This is extremely urgent! My daughter’s birthday is tomorrow and I need your product ASAP! Can we finalize the transaction outside Etsy immediately?”

4) Unusual Payment Methods

Beware of buyers insisting on unconventional payment methods outside of Etsy’s secure platform like gift cards or Bitcoin transactions.

Example:

"I want to buy your product but due to some issues with my bank, I can only pay via gift cards or Bitcoin transactions. Is that okay with you?”

5) Suspicious Messages and Links

Messages containing malicious links leading to malware-infected websites are common spamming techniques used by scammers. Clicking such links can put your username, password, and other sensitive data at risk.

Example:

"Your product looks amazing! Can you provide more details? Check out my specifications [suspicious link] here.”

6) Overpayment Scams

In overpayment scams, the buyer sends a cashier’s check larger than the actual purchase price asking you to refund them the excess amount – but here’s the catch: this check is counterfeit.

Example:

"My apologies for the confusion but it appears that I've sent a cashier's check overpaying for the item - could you refund me the excess amount once you receive it?”

Responding to Phishing Attempts on Etsy

Should you suspect that an email, text message, or phone call is a phishing attempt while using Etsy, following these steps can help protect both your personal and financial information:

Online Messages

  1. Don’t Open It: If you suspect a message might be a phishing attempt, avoid opening it as this could compromise your security.
  2. Delete Immediately: Get rid of the suspicious message immediately to prevent accidental opening in the future.
  3. Avoid Attachments and Links: Do not download any attachments or click on any links within the suspicious message; they could lead to harmful malware or fraudulent websites.
  4. Never Reply: Ignore all requests made by the sender and do not engage with them further.
  5. Report It: Report the incident to Etsy’s support team so they can take appropriate action.

Phone Calls

If you receive a phone call that may be part of a phishing attempt:

  1. End The Call Immediately: Don’t hesitate to hang up if something feels off about the conversation.
  2. Don’t Respond To Requests: Authentic organizations will never request sensitive information over a call; resist giving out any such details.

Remember: Your safety comes first! Always be vigilant when dealing with unknown contacts or suspicious messages on e-commerce platforms like Etsy.

Wrapping Up:

In conclusion, vigilance and caution are key in protecting oneself from scams on Etsy. Be aware of red flags such as requests for personal details, overpayment offers and insistence on off-site communication. Always ensure messages are authentic by checking for Etsy's verification badge. If you encounter suspicious activity, promptly mark the message as spam and contact both Etsy Support and local law enforcement if necessary to safeguard your interests.

FAQ

How to Safeguard Your Etsy Business from Spam and Fraudulent Activities
How can I identify a scam message on Etsy?
Scam messages on Etsy often have common signs: requesting for additional items like pricey gift cards, providing links leading to malware-infected sites or phishing scams disguised as products they wish to buy, offering more money than your listed price (overpayment scam), insisting on off-site communication via personal email, asking vague questions that indicate they haven't read or looked at your listing, refusing to pay through the Etsy Checkout system and showing interest in high-value items.
What should I do if I receive a suspicious message on Etsy?
If you receive a suspicious message on Etsy, it's best not to respond. Instead, mark it as spam by going to "Your Account", navigating "Messages", selecting the suspicious message from your inbox and choosing "Mark as Spam". You can also unsubscribe from email notifications related to that thread if necessary.
What is an overpayment scam on Etsy?
An overpayment scam is when a buyer offers more money than what you're asking for your item. This is one of several techniques scammers use to deceive sellers.
Can I use the Etsy 'Messages' feature for advertising or promotions?
No. The 'Messages' feature must not be used for unsolicited advertising/promotions/donations requests (spam), harassment or abuse of another member violating our Anti-Discrimination Policy; contacting anyone who explicitly asked you not; interfering with other members' transactions/business; exchanging personal contact details aimed at bypassing the checkout process on Etsy.
How can I manage my email preferences on Etsy?
You can manage your email preferences by going to Your account > Click Account Settings > Click Emails tab > Under Your Notifications & Subscriptions sections - select/deselect which emails you'll receive > Choose Save Settings.